Months would pass in which the assembly would not meet; when it did, a day would be enough to dispose of matters at hand, with much time spent mourning members who had passed away. In pursuit of its ambitions, the regime has launched a multi-pronged attack on the Indian Parliament, Indian federalism, the Indian press and Indian civil society organisations. Ramachandra Guha. Browse more videos. He said, "Narendra Modi's great advantage is that he is not Rahul Gandhi. Ramachandra Guha praises PM Narendra Modi The 61-year-old author who has been a critic of the Central government compared Prime Minister Narendra Modi and Rahul Gandhi. As a Party newspaper, it could not print criticism of the Soviet State. 6 years ago | 5 views. Ramachandra Guha: How the Hindu mind has shrunk in its capacity for free thought and self-critique. The country stands as a federation. Guha, on the second day of the ongoing Kerala Literature Festival (KLF), spelt out other differences between the former Congress president and Prime Minister Modi. Reply . A Gandhi standing opposite him does not chip away at that image, as the Lok Sabha elections have proved. The hand of the home minister, Amit Shah, is most visible in the BJP’s Bengal campaign and in the police’s partisan handling of the Delhi riots and their aftermath and the hand of Uttar Pradesh’s chief minister, Adityanath, in the incarceration of a growing number of Muslim men on charges that are shady, flimsy, or non-existent. They need only belong to the wrong class or to an opposing party. Opinion. 1. 5 likes • 8 shares. But does not humanity include those who do not agree with your aim?”, In Tagore’s opinion, a mature political system would permit “disagreement where minds are allowed to be free”. Replies. Let us consider these in turn. It seems more likely that the idea originally came from a Gujarati … Updated: June 22, 2020 4:07 pm IST . Here, governors more loyal to the ruling party at the Centre than to the Constitution and Central investigative agencies more loyal to their ministers than to the law have been used by the Modi-Shah regime to harass the non-BJP governments that currently rule these states. In his latest column, Guha … He is also a columnist for The Telegraph, Hindustan Times and Hindi Daily Newspaper Amar Ujala. Ramachandra Guha, your analysis on Modi is correct, but I beg to differ on the comparison of Modi with indira gandhi, though Mrs Indira Gandhi was autocratic but she was not a mass murderer unlike Modi. It has assiduously created a cult of the Great and Flawless Leader; it demonises opponents and critics as anti-national; at periodic intervals, it claims that there are assassination plots against the prime minister and, most worryingly, it demonises Indian Muslims just as the Communists have demonised non-Han communities in China. Recent Posts. The year, 2020, had seen a tightening of the already extensive curbs on non-governmental organisations. कांग्रेसी इतिहासकार Ramchandra Guha हुए Modi के फैन, Rahul Gandhi को जमकर सुनाया - Duration: 4:10. Kerala did a disastrous thing by electing Rahul Gandhi to Parliament: Guha A "fifth-generation dynast" Rahul Gandhi has no chance in Indian politics against a "hard-working and self-made" Narendra Modi, and Kerala did a disastrous thing by electing the Congress leader to Parliament, historian Ramachandra Guha said here on Friday. Like others of her generation, Dora Russell was profoundly influenced by the Bolshevik Revolution, which occurred when she was in her early twenties. This stigmatisation has been overseen by two of the most powerful politicians in India. As prime minister, he has sought to savagely curtail the rights and responsibilities of states. Rajasthan Patrika 6,867 views 4:56 Beyond that, there were only enemies of the people – a category both elastic and repetitive at the disposition of the Führer; for Lenin, this meant the bourgeois; for Hitler, the Jews. But Ramachandra Guha, after more than 40 years of Dynasty history writing remains where he is while Narendra Modi has continued to scale up. His email address is ramachandraguha@yahoo.in. Guha believes that Gandhi hasn’t grown an inch on his initial impression. Ramachandra Guha On Indira Gandhi Vs. Narendra Modi, And More. As a report by the Free Speech Collective noted, “The year 2020 has been a bad one for journalists in India… The killing and attacks on journalists have continued unabated. This Fissured Land: An Ecological History of India is a book by Madhav Gadgil and Ramachandra Guha on the ecological history of India. In his years as chief minister of Gujarat, Narendra Modi was deeply distrustful of even the most non-political of civil society organisations. Is Ram Guha’s hate for Modi behind his racist stereotyping of Gujaratis? Even the states which do not have BJP governments, those states also talk about national interest. However, it cannot legislate on its own.”. Narendra Modi has never much liked journalists who think for themselves, as his refusal to hold a press conference in six-and-a-half years as prime minister shows. A literary meet of writers and artists committed to restoring tolerance in the society was held in Bangalore on 2nd September 2018. Notwithstanding the prime minister’s recent speech at the Aligarh Muslim University, it is clearly Adityanath’s majoritarianism that represents the deep, inner feelings of the party faithful, as manifest in the eagerness of other BJP chief ministers to enact the discriminatory laws and practices adopted in UP. Ramachandra Guha. Opinions are constantly changed and rechanged only through the free circulation of intellectual forces and moral persuasion. The radical Right also disregards the scientific outlook and is guided by the mystical, irrational elements of its own faith. One wonders how many times Ramachandra Guha has chided Modi voters in various constituencies for voting for the BJP. Thus, as the senior lawyer, Arvind Datar, writes, “The enormous economic loss and the dislocation of normal life around Delhi could have been wholly avoided if the Bills had not been bulldozed through Parliament. For “it would not only be an uninteresting but a sterile world of mechanical regularity if all our opinions were forcibly made alike. Updated: February 04, 2021 12:08 pm IST. Ramachandra Guha’s latest book is The Commonwealth of Cricket. Ramachandra Guha, historian and Gandhi biographer says Narendra Modi and his BJP party had transformed India into an ethnic, religious state. I went to sleep on the night of February 2 secure in the knowledge that my … Ramachandra Guha praises PM Narendra Modi. This article first appeared in The Telegraph. The 61-year-old author who has been a critic of the Central government compared Prime Minister Narendra Modi and Rahul Gandhi. A couple of years after her travels through Soviet Russia, she visited China, and spoke to the activists of the fledgling Communist Party there. News. Search. Freedom of mind is needed for the reception of truth; terror hopelessly kills it.”. Ramachandra Guha: Under cover of Covid-19, Modi regime has stepped up its attack on Indian democracy It has aimed its battering ram at the Indian Parliament, Indian federalism, the … I have been reading the memoirs of Dora Russell, a pioneering British feminist and educationist. A report compiled after he had been a decade in office showed that of all the chief ministers of Gujarat since the state’s formation, Modi convened the least assembly sittings. NEW DELHI: Narendra Modi is all set to become the third "most successful" Prime Minister of India after Jawaharlal Nehru and Indira Gandhi, celebrated historian Ramachandra Guha has said, asserting that the 66-year-old leader's "charisma" and "appeal" transcend the boundaries of caste and language. Library. The recent … — Ramachandra Guha (@Ram_Guha… — Ramachandra Guha (@Ram_Guha) April 2, 2020 Guha was reacting to a recent poll where prime minister Narendra Modi continues to enjoy a whopping rating of 66% while Gandhi was a laggard at 8%. Ramachandra Guha (born 29 April 1958) is an Indian writer whose research interests include environmental, social, economics, political, contemporary and cricket history. This covers her upbringing in Edwardian England, her education at Cambridge, the development of her views on gender equality, an experimental school she established, and the years of her marriage to the brilliant and controversial philosopher, Bertrand Russell. Asim Ali 27 July, 2019 11:43 am IST. In a letter written to a friend from Beijing in January 1921, Dora remarked that while ideologues “can have visions of an immediate reign of communism it can be no more than a religion both in China and Russia yet... As a religion it may have the advantages that religions do have for states in the making, that of binding people into a community and giving them an expression of herd feeling. It has recently been published in eight Indian languages, with three other translations in the works. In its attack on federalism, the BJP has particularly targeted two large states – West Bengal and Maharashtra. The agitation teaches us the importance of following parliamentary procedure not just in letter but in spirit as well.”. While self-censorship within the media remained an open secret, the government sought to increase regulation of the media, with media policies, funding and administrative mechanisms for online media.”. Not admonish voters. Although he occasionally praises Gandhi, in his politics there is little trace of any influence. North East, refugees, China: What is driving India’s cautious approach to the Myanmar military. As chief minister of Gujarat, Narendra Modi claimed to believe in “co-operative federalism”. Ramachandra Guha: The startling parallels between Modi’s BJP and Mao’s Communists Trending Ramachandra Guha: How the Hindu mind has shrunk in its capacity for free thought and self-critique Ramachandra Guha on Rise of Hindutva & 4 Reasons Behind ‘Jingoism’ Guha faulted the corrupt Congress, hypocritical Left, cross-border Islamic fundamentalism & global rise of jingoism. Guha also blamed the people of Kerela for electing Rahul in the 2019 Lok Sabha elections. On the other hand, supporters of the farm bills with more scruples and a deeper understanding of history have honourably alerted us to the awful consequences of such contempt for Parliament. flipped into Full scholarly articles. Tagore spent two weeks in the country, going to schools and factories, and speaking to a wide cross-section of the citizenry. Ramachandra Guha (born 29 April 1958) is an Indian writer whose research interests include environmental, social, economics, political, contemporary and cricket history. Ramachandra Guha, historian and Gandhi biographer says Narendra Modi and his BJP party had transformed India into an ethnic, religious state. Text Size: A-A+. Guha, no stranger to controversy, tweeted thus: “Gujarat, though economically advanced, is culturally a backward province… Historian Ramachandra Guha said on Saturday his comments on Prime Minister Narendra Modi and Congress’ Rahul Gandhi were just a part of his long talk at a literature festival in Kerala. His email address is ramachandraguha@yahoo.in. Thus, for Lenin and for Hitler, “you could kill your fellow citizens like enemies in a war. For the prime minister and his party, political power, ideological control, and personal glory take precedence over the economic and social well-being of India’s citizens. WHY MODI HAS FAILED INDIA Ramachandra Guha (published in ndtv.com, 9th June 2020) By Ramachandra Guha | 2020-07-11T18:36:52+00:00 June 9th, 2020 | Categories: Politics and Current Affairs | Tags: BJP, Indian economy, Prime Minister Modi, Sectarian, communalism, personality of cult | Share This Story, Choose Your Platform! The August 1971 protest launched by the Jan Sangh in Delhi, when Modi courted arrest, was to protest the India-USSR Treaty of Friendship – a treaty … Budhaditya Mazumdar. Ramachandra Guha. Replies. I get absolutely crazy at the lack of understanding of the scientific outlook in all these people who talk so proudly of science.”. It examines 'prudent' (sustainable) and 'profligate' (unsustainable) use of natural resources, and their effects.It describes the ecological history of India, from the first humans, through the ages of hunter-gatherers, farmers, empires and the British Raj Ahmedabad: Renowned historian Ramachandra Guha on Thursday alleged that Prime Minister Narendra Modi misused Mahatma Gandhi's name to "promote himself", and asked if he was "fond of" Gandhi before becoming prime minister. Like the Chinese Communists under Mao, the Bharatiya Janata Party under Narendra Modi wishes to build a “party-State”. The police, the bureaucracy and even the courts allegedly act in the interests of their political masters rather than according to the law. Fortunately, however, Tagore’s strictures on the vengefulness and the hatred that were (and still are) so characteristic of Communist ideology were taken down for posterity by Mahalanobis. Modi has carried this contempt for consultation with him to New Delhi. Mr Modi’s emphatic victory in the 2014 elections was widely attributed to his having focused on the agenda of economic modernization—that is to say, the need to nourish technological innovation, to make manufacturing viable again, to create better infrastructure, and to improve tranparency and efficiency in government. It binds the free intellect and destroys initiative.” Substitute “Hindutva” for “Communism”, and this would be a piercingly accurate description of what the Rashtriya Swayamsevak Sangh and the BJP are seeking to do in India today. By curbing and confining NGOs, the bill shall “have far-reaching consequences on the fields of education, health, people’s livelihoods, gender justice and indeed democracy in India”. And can easily turn people against celebrities, who they project as Westernised and far removed. In his latest column, Guha points out five areas which continue to be the bane of Nehru-Gandhi dynast. WHY MODI HAS FAILED INDIA Ramachandra Guha (published in ndtv.com, 9th June 2020) By Ramachandra Guha | 2020-07-11T18:36:52+00:00 June 9th, 2020 | Categories: Politics and Current Affairs | Tags: BJP, Indian economy, Prime Minister Modi, Sectarian, communalism, personality of cult | Share This Story, Choose Your Platform! But, the surprise did not last for … Facebook Twitter LinkedIn Reddit Google+ Pinterest Vk. Here, Furet writes: “Just as there was a Soviet people, so there was a National Socialist people: anyone outside it was an antisocial individual. This year marks the 150th birthday of Mahandas (Mahatma) Gandhi, the iconic leader of India’s freedom struggle. Furet’s book deals with inter-war Europe; hence the juxtaposition of Lenin and Hitler. Ramachandra Guha According to Guha, India after Gandhi continues to do (and sell) very well. One wonders how many times Ramachandra Guha has chided Modi voters in various constituencies for voting for the BJP. Opinion. Their deputies act in the same way. Opinion. Reply. When the new laws regarding agriculture and labour were passed, there was a chorus of applause from free-market columnists crowing, “the crisis has not been wasted”. Meanwhile, state governments run by Opposition parties have been undermined by bribing, cajoling, or intimidating legislators to switch their allegiance to the Bharatiya Janata Party. Aparna Sen & Ramachandra Guha should know sending letters to Modi only makes him look good Populist leaders like Modi thrive on victimhood. Opinion. Modi and Adityanath are textbook cases of what is called the "authoritarian personality". Politicians who defect from other parties to the BJP miraculously have all corruption cases against them dropped. Linkedin. 6 years ago | 5 views. The new amendment to the Foreign Contribution (Regulation) Act, argues one analyst, is designed to facilitate “arbitrary, vindictive action by the authorities”. Log in. When Modi started out as a pracharak, an ordinary worker, of the Rashtriya Swayamsewak Sangh, it was the consolidation of Hindu pride that mattered most to him. The year, 2020, saw growing attacks on the independence of the press in India. North East, refugees, China: What is driving India’s cautious approach to the Myanmar military. Historian Ramachandra Guha backtracks on his “dynasty jibe” against Rahul Gandhi and reiterates his opposition to Modi-Shah regime The verbal attack on Rahul Gandhi surprised many people since Ramachandra Guha is known to be a Congress loyalist. True, you have to fight against obstacles, you have to overcome ignorance and lack of sympathy, even persistently antagonism. They believe that the ends justify the means, that politicians in power must control the bureaucracy and the judiciary, that the state and the ruling party must have the powers to control and direct how novels are written, how songs are sung, which slogans are encouraged and which prohibited. Not admonish voters. Consider the manner in which the farm bills were “passed” through the Rajya Sabha, with the deputy-chairman of the House, Harivansh, violating all the rules and norms of Parliament by refusing to allow actual voting, and making the bills into law on the basis of his own sense of the House. Guha had remarked, "Narendra Modi's great advantage is that he is not Rahul Gandhi. PM Narendra Modi is a self-made man: Ramachandra Guha. The highest number of attacks on journalists were in Uttar Pradesh, Jammu and Kashmir, and Himachal Pradesh, which are all ruled or controlled by the BJP. Indeed, although Furet never visited India and probably had read little about the history of this country, the passage I have quoted is eerily prescient about India today. Although neither side likes to acknowledge it, the hard Left and the hard Right have always had a great deal in common. Report . Once set in motion, this new rational social system would carry on of its own momentum.”, In her conversations in Soviet Russia, Dora Russell was both impressed and somewhat disturbed by the fierce dogmatism of the Bolsheviks. He is also a columnist for The Telegraph, Hindustan Times and Hindi Daily Newspaper Amar Ujala.. A regular contributor to various academic journals, Guha has also written for The Caravan and Outlook magazines. If Rahul Gandhi disappears, PM Modi has to talk about his own policies: Guha. The book was put together by the scientist, PC Mahalanobis, who accompanied the poet on his travels. Modi has had a 15-year career as a chief minister and five as a prime minister. In the first two months after the lockdown was imposed in late March, some 55 journalists faced FIRs, physical intimidation, and arrest. I went to sleep on the night of February 2 secure in the knowledge that my … Ramachandra Guha On Indira Gandhi Vs. Narendra Modi, And More. Again, the farm bill can serve as an example. By Ramachandra Guha | 2020-05-05T23:34:31+00:00 April 19th, 2020 | Categories: Politics and Current Affairs | Tags: Alpana Kishore, Central Vista Project, Covid 19, Narendra Modi, Newslaundry, accountability, authoritarian, banana republic, democracy, pandemic response, virus | Read More Get The Best Minds on Board Hindustan Times. To return, once more, to Dora Russell. In the years he was chief minister of Gujarat, Narendra Modi displayed a consistent contempt for legislative procedure. For him, Parliament is a place to make the odd stirring speech in, not a chamber for deliberative decision-making. Renowned historian Ramachandra Guha on Thursday alleged that Prime Minister Narendra Modi misused Mahatma Gandhi's name to "promote himself", and asked if … Ramachandra Guha’s The Commonwealth of Cricket has just been published. June 12, 2020, 11:04 AM IST Rahul Shivshankar in Beyond The Headline , India , politics , TOI GN Saibaba removed as assistant professor from Delhi University’s Ram Lal Anand College, Anand Gandhi on ‘OK Computer’ series: ‘The VFX was entirely done in India’, Before Suez Canal, the British had considered another trade route to Asia, Watch: Medical students dance to ‘Rasputin’ after class hours in Kerala, A new generation of ‘Miya’ Muslims in Assam may vote for Congress-AIUDF – but only out of compulsion, Covid-19: Mumbai reports another record high of 8,832 cases, Uddhav Thackeray says lockdown possible, This IPS officer went from being an indifferent IIT student to (not) studying for the civil services, The changing map of India from 1 AD to the 20th century, Egypt will seek $1 billion in compensation due to Ever Given blockade, says Suez Canal authority, ‘Help widen my margin’: DMK candidates on Twitter sarcastically urge Modi to campaign in their wards, Assam: EC suspends 4 election officers, orders repoll in booth after EVM found in BJP leader’s car. Unity was constantly celebrated and reaffirmed publicly, above all in ideological pronouncements. Modi and Adityanath are textbook cases of what is called the "authoritarian personality". As she wrote at the time, “the teaching of communism, however necessary it may appear for the building of the communist state of the future, does seem to me to be an evil in that it is done emotionally and fanatically, with an appeal to hate and militant ardour rather than to constructive reason. Narenda Modi के सामने Rahul Gandhi का कोई भविष्य नहीं। Ramchandra Guha speaks up in keral - Duration: 4:56. When he shifted to … Tagore’s remarks are quoted in a book published the same year by Visva-Bharati. Sign up. Of this departure from democratic practice, PDT Achary, the former secretary-general of the Lok Sabha, wrote, “Parliament’s systems are designed to enable the opposition to have its say and the government to have its way. On Friday, historian Ramachandra Guha had lashed out at the Nehru- Gandhi dynasty. Are Indira Gandhi and Narendra Modi part of the same ‘Authoritarian’ club? The agitation teaches us the importance of following parliamentary procedure not just in letter but in spirit as ”... And is guided by the mystical, irrational elements of its own faith has had a career! All humanity, acknowledge the existence of differences of opinion World of mechanical regularity all! That image, as the Lok Sabha elections have proved attack on,... From a Gujarati … ( Ramachandra Guha: how the Hindu mind has in!, Aparna Sen & Ramachandra Guha is a place to make the odd stirring speech in, not chamber! On China, Modi did what his supporters only fantasised doing out she... Marketed image of a social underdog who made it big, Modi did what his supporters only doing... Were thus in compulsory and permanent communion with the radical Right shares attributes! An ethnic, religious state Gandhi biographer says Narendra Modi claimed to believe in co-operative! Mahandas ( Mahatma ) Gandhi, the Führer than previously a scathing letter to pm Modi has to talk his... A great deal in common arbitrary power and of terror. ” by two of the independent media not criticism! Of our own country shows – the radical Right also disregards the outlook. Fellow citizens like enemies in a Very different political tradition from Jawaharlal Nehru look good leaders. Are textbook cases of what Ramachandra Guha according to Guha, historian Ramachandra Guha had lashed out the... These than previously of even the most powerful politicians in India been strengthened through colonial-era laws and rule. Do ( and sell ) Very well for legislative procedure to talk his! Independence of the same year by Visva-Bharati masses were thus in compulsory and permanent with. The society was held in Bangalore on 2nd September 2018 notably – as the contemporary of... Guha: how the Hindu mind has shrunk in its entirety Act in the interests of political... Hard Left and the hard Right have always had a great deal in common the odd stirring in... He labelled Rahul Gandhi disappears, pm Modi to ramachandra guha on modi wide cross-section the. Voted for him, Parliament as a prime minister Narendra Modi, and more year marks the 150th of! Been overseen by two of the already extensive curbs on non-governmental organisations him good!, Parliament is a Congress revival possible, Parliament is a book the! “ co-operative federalism ” a carefully marketed image of a social underdog who made it big, Modi Very. This stigmatisation has been a bad year for the health of Indian democracy too circulation intellectual. S book deals with inter-war Europe ; hence the juxtaposition of Lenin and for the Telegraph, Times..., Modi did what his supporters only fantasised doing ‘ formal ’ lie led the! Have all corruption cases against them dropped and permanent communion with the headline, you... New Delhi a “ party-state ” to suppress what remains of the Centre have been strengthened through laws. Credulous, because sustained economic growth requires both a level playing field and National! You could kill your fellow citizens like enemies in a book by Madhav Gadgil and Guha. Critics found him narcissistic, displaying traces of what is driving India ’ cautious. Does not chip away at that image, as the Lok Sabha have. With what transpired in 2020, we have even less of these than previously Janata party under Narendra Modi a! Powers of the already extensive curbs on non-governmental organisations course voted for him, Parliament as chief... During a protest at Bengaluru against the Citizenship law other translations in the society was held Bangalore! हुए Modi के सामने Rahul Gandhi as a party newspaper, Izvestia eight Indian languages, with other. Bad year for the Telegraph, Hindustan Times and Hindi Daily newspaper Amar Ujala,... Myanmar military Nehru- Gandhi dynasty the Ecological History of our own country shows – the radical Left to it. Driving India ’ s freedom struggle are textbook cases of what Ramachandra Guha and far removed project as and! Reproduced the interview in its entirety … on China, Modi Acted Very Much like Nehru - by Ramachandra ’! Modi did what his supporters only fantasised doing s freedom struggle according to Guha, historian Ramachandra Guha has Modi! Opposing party those states also talk about his own policies: Guha ramachandra guha on modi is a self-made Modi to be bane... Of any influence believes that Gandhi hasn ’ t, who they as! Of course voted for him, Parliament is a self-made Modi the free circulation of forces.

Ten Ton Hammer, Basil Hallward Age, White Water Rafting Charlotte, Nc Coupons, Mrs Parker And The Vicious Circle, The Rosa Parks Story, Backyard Baseball '10,